What Is the Difference Between Ice Pick, Boxcar and Rolling Acne Scars?

Ice pick scars are narrow, deep holes, usually under 2 mm wide. Boxcar scars are wider, round or oval dips with sharp, steep edges. Rolling scars are broad, soft-edged depressions that make the skin look wavy, caused by bands pulling the surface down. Each type sits at a different depth, so each responds to different treatments, and most people have a mix of all three.
All Three Are Depressed Scars
Ice pick, boxcar and rolling scars belong to the same family, called atrophic scars. In each case, inflammation from acne destroyed collagen and the skin healed with a dip instead of a smooth surface. What makes them different is the shape, the width and the depth of that dip, and whether the skin is being pulled down from below. These details matter because a treatment that works well for one type may do very little for another. Naming your scar types correctly is the first step towards a plan that actually works.
A Side-by-Side Comparison
| Ice pick | Boxcar | Rolling | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Width | Very narrow, under about 2 mm | About 1.5 to 4 mm or more | Broad, often over 4 mm |
| Edges | Sharp, like a puncture | Sharp, steep walls | Soft, sloping |
| Depth | Deep, narrowing as it goes down | Shallow to deep, flat base | Shallow but wide |
| Cause of the dip | Deep, narrow tissue loss | Wider loss of collagen | Fibrous bands tethering skin |
| Common areas | Cheeks, temples | Cheeks, temples | Lower cheeks, jaw |
Ice Pick Scars Are Narrow and Deep
Ice pick scars look like small, deep holes, as if the skin had been pricked with a sharp tool. They are usually narrower than 2 mm at the surface but can extend deep into the skin, narrowing like a V as they go down. Because the opening is small and the depth is great, surface treatments often cannot reach the bottom. This makes ice pick scars one of the hardest types to improve with lasers alone. Doctors often use targeted methods that treat each scar individually, such as the TCA CROSS technique, in which a strong acid is applied precisely into the scar to stimulate collagen, or small punch techniques that remove or lift the scar.
Boxcar Scars Have Sharp Walls
Boxcar scars are round, oval or slightly angular dips with steep, well-defined edges and a flat base. They are wider than ice pick scars and can be shallow or deep. Shallow boxcar scars often respond well to resurfacing treatments that smooth the edges and stimulate new collagen, such as fractional lasers and RF microneedling. Deeper boxcar scars may need targeted techniques as well, sometimes combined with fillers or collagen-stimulating injections to raise the base. Because the edges cast clear shadows, softening them can make a big visual difference even if some depth remains.
Softening the edges of a boxcar scar often matters more than filling its full depth.
Rolling Scars Are Tethered From Below
Rolling scars are broad, gentle depressions that give the skin an uneven, wavy look, especially in side lighting. They form when bands of fibrous tissue grow between the skin and the deeper layers and pull the surface downwards. If you gently stretch the skin, rolling scars often flatten out, which is one way doctors recognise them. Because the problem is the band underneath, surface treatments alone rarely fix them well. Subcision, a technique in which a needle or blunt cannula is used under the skin to release the bands, is often the key step. Lasers, RF microneedling and sometimes fillers or skin boosters are then used to improve the surface and volume.
A Simple Way to Tell Them Apart
- Look straight on Tiny deep holes suggest ice pick scars.
- Check the edges Sharp walls with a flat floor suggest boxcar scars.
- Use side light Soft waves and shadows suggest rolling scars.
- Stretch gently Dips that flatten when stretched are often rolling scars.
- Confirm with a doctor Many scars are mixed and need expert grading.
Most People Have a Mix
It is rare to have only one type of scar. A typical cheek might have a few ice pick scars near the centre, some boxcar scars scattered around and an area of rolling scars towards the jaw. This is why a single treatment rarely gives the full result people hope for. A good plan treats each type with the tool that suits it, often in the same session or over a series of sessions. For example, subcision might release rolling scars, a targeted acid treatment might address ice pick scars and RF microneedling might smooth the whole area.
Treatments Matched to Scar Type
| Scar type | Approaches often considered |
|---|---|
| Ice pick | TCA CROSS, punch techniques, then resurfacing |
| Shallow boxcar | Fractional laser, RF microneedling |
| Deep boxcar | Targeted techniques plus resurfacing; sometimes volume support |
| Rolling | Subcision, then RF microneedling or laser; sometimes fillers or boosters |
You can read about one commonly used option on our Potenza RF microneedling page, and about resurfacing on the fractional laser page.
Raised Scars Are a Different Category
Ice pick, boxcar and rolling scars are all depressions. Raised acne scars, called hypertrophic scars and keloids, sit above the skin and are caused by too much collagen rather than too little. They are more common on the chest, back, shoulders and jawline. Treatments for raised scars are very different, often involving injections to flatten them, silicone products or specific lasers. If you have both raised and depressed scars, tell the doctor, because some treatments for depressed scars can worsen raised ones.
Why Lighting and Photos Matter
Scar types can look different depending on how light hits the skin. Overhead light can make rolling scars look dramatic, while direct front light can make them almost disappear. Ice pick scars can look like large pores in some lighting. For an accurate assessment, doctors examine the skin under different angles of light, and many clinics take standardised photos. When you track your own progress, use the same lighting and position every time so that changes are real rather than caused by the light.
Realistic Expectations by Scar Type
Treatment can improve all three types, but results differ. Rolling scars often show clear improvement after subcision and resurfacing. Shallow boxcar scars tend to respond well to a series of resurfacing sessions. Deep ice pick and deep boxcar scars usually improve more slowly and may never disappear completely. Most people see meaningful improvement rather than perfectly smooth skin. A doctor who explains the expected improvement for each scar type, rather than promising complete removal, is giving you a more honest picture.
Skin Tone Changes the Treatment Choice
In medium to darker skin tones, aggressive resurfacing lasers can cause long-lasting dark marks. Doctors may prefer RF microneedling, gentler fractional settings and careful pre and post-treatment care to reduce this risk. This does not mean scars cannot be treated, only that the tools and settings are chosen with skin tone in mind.
Before Your Scar Consultation
- Take photos in daylight from the front and both sides.
- Make sure active acne is under control or mention current breakouts.
- List previous scar treatments and how your skin responded.
- Mention any tendency to raised scars or dark marks.
- Note how much downtime you can accept on your trip.
A doctor consultation is where the scar types are confirmed and the plan is built.
Say this at your consultation
"I think I have rolling scars on my lower cheeks."
"Which of my scars are ice pick and which are boxcar?"
"Can subcision and microneedling be done on the same trip?"
Frequently Asked Questions
Which acne scar type is hardest to treat?
Deep ice pick scars are usually the hardest, because their narrow depth is difficult for surface treatments to reach.
Can fillers fix rolling scars?
Fillers can lift some rolling scars, but releasing the bands with subcision is often needed first for a lasting result.
Are enlarged pores the same as ice pick scars?
No. Pores are natural openings, while ice pick scars are deeper and usually irregular. A doctor can tell them apart.
How many sessions do mixed scars need?
Usually several, spaced weeks apart. The number depends on scar depth, type and the treatments used.
Can I treat scars in one trip?
You can usually start in one trip, but most people need more than one session for full improvement.
Not Sure Which Scars You Have?
Send us daylight photos from the front and sides. Our English-speaking team will help you prepare for a scar consultation.
Book Your ConsultationReferences
- Jacob CI et al. — Acne scarring: a classification system and review of treatment options. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology.
- Dermatologic Surgery — subcision and combination treatment for atrophic acne scars.
- American Academy of Dermatology — acne scar treatment overview.
This guide was prepared and reviewed by our clinical team using publicly available dermatology information. It is general information, not medical advice.






